Advanced Search
Advanced Search
View: Front

Three-sided relief with a scene of weighing ("the Boston Throne")

Greek
Classical Period
about 460 B.C.

Medium/Technique Marble, Dolomitic from the Greek island of Thasos
Dimensions Overall: 82 x 161 cm (32 5/16 x 63 3/8 in.)
Framed (Rolling steel pedestal/ removable top steel pallet): 100.3 x 186.7 x 95.3 cm (39 1/2 x 73 1/2 x 37 1/2 in.)
Weight: 1587.59 kg (3500 lb.)
Credit Line Henry Lillie Pierce Fund
Accession Number08.205
ClassificationsArchitectural elements
The most satisfying interpretation of the enigmatic scene on the front panel of this three-sided marble relief casts Aphrodite, on the left, in her role as a goddess of fate. Her son Eros, the winged figure at center, holds a scale, whose crossbar (now missing) was made separately, probably out of metal, and attached into three slots cut in the stone. The weights of the scale, visible on either side of Eros, are sculpted with two young men whose hands are bound above their heads. At the right, the sorrowful female is Demeter, goddess of grain, who is identified by a pomegranate, an emblem of agricultural fertility. The three deities have gathered to determine for how long Demeter's daughter, Persephone, was obliged to stay in the Underworld with her abductor, Hades. The figures on the weights must represent the "lots" of the contenders-lover and mother-for Persephone. It was ultimately decided that Persephone ought to spend more of each year aboveground with Demeter, and the higher position of the weight near her indicates her triumph-a testament to the high esteem in which the ancient Greeks held a mother's love.

The graceful scrolls rising at the corners of the relief show that it was the crowning element of some structure, possibly an altar. It was found in Rome not far from the findspot of a famous marble sculpture of similar shape and material dedicated to Aphrodite, the so-called Ludovisi Throne. Both of these three-sided reliefs were transported to Rome in antiquity, as either spoils of war or prized collection pieces, from somewhere in Greece or from one of the Greek colonies of southern Italy. The unusual pieces have occasionally been alleged to be forgeries, but scientific studies of their surface and historical research on their provenance provide strong evidence of their authenticity.

Catalogue Raisonné Sculpture in Stone (MFA), no. 030; Sculpture in Stone and Bronze (MFA), p. 107 (additional published references); Highlights: Classical Art (MFA), p. 088-089.
DescriptionA three-sided relief cut from a single block. Seated on the right is Demeter with her head veiled in mourning for her daughter Persephone. Aphrodite is seated opposite consulting with her son Eros at the center who holds the scales (made from a separate piece of marble) to determine how long Persephone will stay in the Underworld.
Short sides: a boy with a lyre; an old nurse.
Perhaps, the relief served as an enclosure for an outdoor altar.

"Sculpture in Stone" no. 30, pp. 20-25

Portions of the surface have been carefully cleaned, but some incrustation remains, especially on the garment of the figure on the left wing, and marks left by the roots of plants are visible in places. The Ludovisi relief and the Warren relief show similar flaws and the same light grayish-brown patina.

The reliefs themselves have suffered comparatively slight injuries. On the left wing the lower temination of the scroll, which in this case projected beyond the end of the slab, is lost, together with the ends of the old woman's feet. The edges of the palmettes at the corners are broken off, and there are small breaks along the lower edges at the three sides, especially at the angles. The noses of all five figures, the toes of the winged youth, the plectron of the lyre-player, and the pegs of the lyre are damaged.

Certain other changes were produced, partly by accident and partly by design, in Roman times, when the relief was removed from its original position. As on the Ludovisi relief, marks made by crowbars, used to pry the monument from its pedestal, are visible at several places along the bottom, on both the outer and the inner faces. On the left wing an irregular groove runs across the bottom surface close to the corner, and continues obliquely upward across the face of the relief.

Scientific Analysis:
Marble has been scientifically tested with X-Ray Diffraction and determined to be Dolomitic.
Harvard Lab No. HI090: Isotope ratios - delta13C +3.48 / delta18O -3.06, Attribution - Thasos-Cape Vathy, Justification - Dolomitic by XRD.
Provenance1894: Found in Rome in a private villa on via Boncampagni in the same region as the Ludovisi relief, in the area of the ancient Gardens of Sallust (the Ludovisi Quarter) on the Pincian Hill; acquired successively by Valenzi, Jandolo, Martinetti, and Hartwig before being purchased by Edward Perry Warren in 1896; purchased by MFA from Edward Perry Warren, May 5, 1908, for $ 3,600.00