Sylvester Koehler: Exploring Print History


Unidentified artist, Sylvester Rosa Koehler (detail), probably 1890s. Photograph, tintype. Source unidentified, 2023.


Unidentified artist, Sylvester Rosa Koehler (detail), probably 1890s. Photograph, tintype. Source unidentified, 2023.
In 1892 the MFA hosted a landmark exhibition on the history and technology of printing. Organized by Sylvester Rosa Koehler (1837–1900), the MFA’s first curator of prints and drawings, the “Exhibition Illustrating the Technical Methods of the Reproductive Arts from the 15th Century to the Present Time, with Special Reference to the Photo-Mechanical Processes” included more than 700 works that traced the history of printing in Europe and the United States. The Boston show was the third in a sequence Koehler organized on this theme, following earlier versions in Washington, DC, and Cincinnati. Boston’s version was the most ambitious. Koehler aspired to capture every method ever devised of putting ink to paper, and document them in a detailed object-by-object catalogue with extensive commentary.
“Sylvester Koehler: Exploring Print History” resurrects the 1892 exhibition and its catalogue, making them accessible in today’s digital age. Resources related to the show—and Koehler’s work more broadly—are available together online for the first time, anchored by an interactive version of the catalogue with links to database records of objects Koehler used (or may have used) in the original exhibition. Many of the featured works survive today in the MFA’s collection and, taken together, provide an unparalleled resource for the history of printing techniques and technology in the 19th century. Among the rarest materials, which record the intersection between printmaking and photography, are many examples that exist practically nowhere else.
This is not, in the strictest sense, a recreation of the show; for while it documents as many of the exact objects Koehler displayed as possible, it has not been possible to locate and confirm every object that was in the exhibition. In some cases, multiple candidates have been identified for an entry. With that in mind, this project reflects Koehler’s entrepreneurial spirit. He was energetic, pragmatic, and omnivorous, and would likely have appreciated both the new technology utilized here and the flexibility required to make it as useful and complete as it can be.
Image Gallery
It’s difficult to capture the extraordinary scope of the exhibition, which featured everything from Renaissance woodcuts and engravings to all manner of up-to-date photomechanical printing techniques. These images represent the outstanding variety of works visitors would have encountered upon visiting the show in 1892.

Chromochalcography. Gift of Sylvester Rosa Koehler. Cat. No. 229.
Louis-Marin Bonnet (after François Boucher), head of a girl turned to the right, 1767
This study of a young girl was one of eighteen examples illustrating how the intaglio technique of copper engraving, normally a black-and-white process, could be applied to color printing by using multiple plates to create the image. The exhibition’s section on intaglio featured examples of mezzotint, aquatint, etching, and drypoint, as well as the crayon manner seen here.

Etching. Gift of Sylvester Rosa Koehler. Cat. No. 117.
Henry Rankin Poore, Peter Moran at Work Etching, before 1898
Over the course of his career, Koehler gathered historic and contemporary images that captured printmakers engaged in their craft. Koehler knew the sitter of this etching, Peter Moran, having featured his work in American Art Review and included it in his 1885 book Etching: An Outline of Its Technical Processes and its History, with Some Remarks on Collections and Collecting.

Photoglyphic engraving. Gift of Walter Rowlands. Cat. No. 394.
William Henry Fox Talbot, The Institute of France, 1858
This was one of three “photoglyphs” by English photography pioneer Henry Fox Talbot included in the exhibition under intaglio processes in the photo-mechanical section. It was published in the Photographic News on November 12, 1858.

Gift of S. A. Schoff. Cat. No. 130.
Stephen Alonzo Schoff, laid by Fillibrown and Charles P. Smith, Portrait of Lincoln, about 1890
A small section of the exhibition focused on how printmakers used etching to lay the groundwork for engraving, essentially as a means to accelerate the process of preparing a plate for printing. This monumental plate shows both techniques. The portrait head of Lincoln is etched, while the jacket shows significant engraving. The MFA also holds several proofs from this plate.

Photomechanical relief process. Gift of Boston Engraving Co. Cat. No. 380.
Boston Engraving Company (after Henry Sandham), Harvard–Yale Football Match, November 21, 1891, 1891
This rare example of dry flong, a mold for casting a stereotype printing plate, is part of a sequence of process materials in the exhibition that demonstrated key steps in reproducing an image in a newspaper. In this instance, the image is a drawing based on a photograph taken at the 1891 Harvard–Yale football game, which took place less than two months before the exhibition opened.

Drypoint. Museum purchase. Cat. No. 102.
Mary Louise McLaughlin, Head of a Girl, 1886
Koehler selected this particular proof to illustrate the process of drypoint, since its white lines are readily visible, as noted in the exhibition catalogue. Koehler also showed McLaughlin’s work in an 1888 print exhibition in Cincinnati, the artist’s hometown.

Photogravure. Gift of Boussod, Valadon & Co. Cat. No. 461.
Boussod, Valadon et Cie., Portrait of Sarah Bernhardt, 1880
The exhibition presented six examples of photo-aquatint and photo-gravure by Boussod, Valadon et Cie., which showed the possibilities for reproducing artworks, whether drawings in graphite or ink, engravings, oil paintings, or photographs. American viewers almost certainly would have recognized internationally acclaimed French stage actor Sarah Bernhardt, pictured here.

Engraving. Gift of Sylvester Rosa Koehler. Cat. No. 146.
Gilles Demarteau (after Carle van Loo), Seated Satyr, 18th century
This work combines the techniques of engraving and etching with the goal of recreating the appearance of a crayon drawing. It has long been credited to French artist Gilles Demarteau, who had three prints in this section of the exhibition.

Etching and aquatint, printed in brown. Gift of Sylvester Rosa Koehler. Cat. No. 177.
Maria Anna Angelica Kauffman, Woman Holding a Child, 1763
Koehler included two prints by Swiss artist Maria Anna Angelica Kauffman in the exhibition’s section on aquatint, a type of etching process. The differences between these works (see also Woman Braiding Her Hair) highlight the great variety of effects printmakers can achieve with aquatint. Throughout his career, Koehler advocated for women artists and printmakers; in 1887, the year he was appointed curator at the MFA, he organized a groundbreaking exhibition of American women etchers.

Enamel photo. Gift of the artist. Cat. No. 346.
Augustus Marshall, Portrait of a Girl, about 1890
At the time of the exhibition, methods of printing photographs that would not fade were highly sought after. Koehler included six examples of photographs printed on porcelain by Boston photographer Augustus Marshall in the section on permanent photography. Marshall created the portraits on porcelain using a process that can also be employed on enamel, glass, or paper.

Woodburytype. Gift of John Walter Osborne. Cat. No. 513.
Walter Bentley Woodbury (after Henry Peach Robinson), A Mountain-Dew Girl: Killarney, 1866.
This is one of the first woodburytypes ever published. Photographer Walter B. Woodbury, who invented the process—or someone working under his supervision—likely made it. Woodburytypes were the most successful reproductions of photographs in the second half of the 19th century and were prized for their subtle tonality. The complexity of the process, and especially the fragility of the surface gelatin, made it a relatively short-lived reproductive technique.

Autoplate. Gift of Sylvester Rosa Koehler. Cat. No. 467.
Calendar for 1879, published by Louis Brown and Company, 1879
This calendar is an early example of photoengraving in the United States. In 1878, around when this calendar was published, the American Institute awarded Louis Brown and Company, the Philadelphia firm that produced it, a medal for their “autoplates.”

Photolithograph, Osborne’s process. Gift of John Walter Osborne. Cat. No. 543.
American Photolithography Co., New York, American Agriculturist, 1866
John Walter Osborne invented a new type of line-transfer printing in Australia in 1859. This extreme reduction—just a few inches high—is one of numerous examples of “Osborne’s Process” in the exhibition. It was among the first specimens Osborne printed in the United States, in 1866, the year he founded the American Photolithographic Company in New York.

Photocollograph (chromatotype), final printing. Gift of E. Bierstadt. Cat. No. 661.
Edward Bierstadt, Portrait of a Lady, about 1890
This rare “chromatotype” (today called a photocollograph) portrait from life by Edward Bierstadt, brother of painter Albert Bierstadt and of photographer Charles Bierstadt, is an early experiment in color photography in the United States.
Print History in 1892: Exhibition Catalogue
See our ongoing effort to create an illustrated version of Sylvester Koehler’s 1892 exhibition. For the first time ever this archival document is available as an accessible and interactive web page with links to illustrated object records.
View CatalogueResources
Explore materials related to Koehler and his work, the exhibition, and print culture up to about 1900.
Timeline
Trace the history of Koehler’s life and the development of print culture in the United States.
Exhibitions
See a list of select exhibitions Koehler helped organize.
Bibliography
For further research see this bibliography of select publications that Koehler either wrote or was involved in producing.
The 1892 Lectures
Read Koehler’s papers “The Photo-Mechanical Processes,” which he presented at the January 14 and 28 and February 25, 1892 meetings of the Society of Arts at MIT, published in Technology Quarterly and Proceedings of the Society of Arts by MIT, vol. 5, no. 3, October 1892, p. 161.
Correspondence
Koehler was a prolific correspondent, and his papers are held in numerous public and private archives around the world, including at the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. The MFA’s Koehler archive has not yet been fully catalogued, though that work is in process.
Art for This Moment
Hidden Figures
For Art for This Moment, the MFA’s blog, Department of Prints and Drawings curators Meghan Melvin and Benjamin Weiss discuss Koehler’s importance in print history and reveal the origins of this Beyond the Gallery project.
Read the EssayTell Us What You Think
Have questions or feedback related to this project? Get in touch with us at [email protected].