Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, Resolves Ownership of Adriaen van Ostade Painting

BOSTON (June 9, 2023)—Susan and Matthew Weatherbie and the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston (MFA), have reached an agreement with the heirs of art dealers Paul Graupe and Arthur Goldschmidt resolving the ownership of Adriaen van Ostade’s painting Customers Conversing in a Tavern (1671), which had been sold to Adolf Hitler in the early 1940s. The agreement allows the painting to be retained and exhibited at the MFA, and donated to the Museum at a future date by the Weatherbies.

By 1937, the Ostade panel was part of the stock of Paul Graupe et Cie., a Paris-based gallery run by the Jewish art dealer Paul Graupe. Graupe and his business partner, Arthur Goldschmidt, who was likewise Jewish, had been compelled to leave Nazi Germany for France due to racial persecution. In 1939, Graupe again fled, first to Switzerland, then to Portugal in 1940, and ultimately to the U.S. in 1941. His gallery stock was left behind in occupied Paris. In 1940, after he was sent to an internment camp and conscripted into service, Goldschmidt fled to the south of France, which was then not occupied.

Before leaving Europe, Graupe asked for Goldschmidt’s help in saving his gallery stock, including Customers Conversing in a Tavern, which he hoped could be sent to Switzerland or the U.S. In February 1941, Goldschmidt negotiated a sale of the Ostade to Karl Haberstock, an agent for Hitler, who traveled freely between occupied and unoccupied France. Goldschmidt was able to immigrate to Cuba later that year, making his way to the U.S. in 1946. Haberstock sold the painting to Hitler’s art adviser and curator, Hans Posse, in April 1941. It was selected for inclusion in the art museum Hitler planned to build in Linz, Austria, the so-called Führermuseum

Customers Conversing in a Tavern was recovered by Allied forces after the end of World War II and shipped to France for restitution. The painting was not claimed by the end of the 1940s, and as a result the French state auctioned it in 1951. It changed hands several times on the European art market before Susan and Matthew Weatherbie bought it, unaware of its Nazi-era history, in 1992. It is one of 28 Dutch and Flemish paintings the Weatherbies pledged to the MFA in 2017.

The parties are pleased to reach this just and fair resolution consistent with the Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art.

“We are happy that these longstanding ownership issues have been resolved so amicably, and we are delighted to display Customers Conversing in a Tavern at the MFA so that it can be shared with the public,” said Susan and Matthew Weatherbie.

“We are so pleased to reach this resolution with the heirs of Paul Graupe and Arthur Goldschmidt and with the Weatherbies,” said Matthew Teitelbaum, Ann and Graham Gund Director. “The story of this painting reminds us that the work of Holocaust-era restitution is still not complete, and that just and equitable resolutions can be found with willing partners.”

The painting has been newly installed in the MFA’s suite of Dutch and Flemish galleries, as part of a grouping with other works by Ostade and his pupil Cornelis Bega from the Museum’s collection. 

Provenance Research

The MFA is a leader in the field of provenance research, employing a full-time Curator for Provenance, who works with curators throughout the Museum to research and document the MFA’s collection on an ongoing basis. Findings are included in the Museum’s online collections database. The MFA follows the highest standards of professional practice in regards to issues of ownership and in its response to claims for works in the collection. If research demonstrates that a work of art has been stolen, confiscated or unlawfully appropriated without subsequent restitution, then the Museum will notify potential claimants, and seek to resolve the matter in an equitable, appropriate and mutually agreeable manner. A list of ownership resolutions at the Museum since the late 1990s can be found here.


Karen Frascona